More Filters
Showing Restaurants 1-18 of 20
  • 1. Homestyle Desserts, Inc

    For more than 30 years this classic Italian bakery has been churning out delicious confections by the thousands, from kosher challah and Italian tricolor cookies, to gluten-free muffins, tasty tarts, and decadent cannoli.   Best of Westchester 2021 - Best Bakery (Italian) Best of Westchester 2020 - Best Bakery (Italian)  Best of Westchester 2019 - Read more...
  • 2. Hudson Creamery

      Best of Westchester 2018 - Best Milkshakes 
  • 3. The Blue Pig

    Vegans rejoice — you can have your ice cream and eat it, too. The Blue Pig has expanded its vegan offerings, with two flavors offered daily. Choices are seasonal and include such favorites as salted caramel swirl and peanut-butter brownie. There are also house-made vegan toppings, so sundaes can be enjoyed every day.   Best Read more...

    4. Baked By Susan

    One of Westchester’s most prolific local bakeries, the much-loved shop moved just a few blocks in 2020 to a brand-new Croton-on-Hudson address with a new location is double the size of the old one, making room for even more sweet treats. Pies are far and away a local favorite, but you can score pastries, cakes, Read more...
  • 5. The Chocolate Chalet

  • 6. Lil’ Chocolate Shoppe

    This Mount Pleasant staple is an old-school chocolatier with a wide selection of truffles, creams, everyday and special occasion confections, and even gifts and specialty items.   Best of Westchester 2021 - Best Chocolate Shop Best of Westchester 2018 - Best Chocolate Shop
  • 7. Penny Lick Ice Cream Co.

    Dark chocolate coconut (the favorite flavor of owner Ellen Sledge) is this inky-black scoop that manages to be every bit as delicious (dare we say even better?) than most cream-and-egg-based ice creams. It took Sledge 30 tries to nail the balance of dark onyx cocoa and coconut milk, and the result is an addictive Mounds-like Read more...
  • 8. La Tulipe Desserts

    One reader called this “the closest thing to a true patisserie in Westchester,” and it’s hard to argue, considering La Tulipe’s fleet of beautifully crafted tarts, French macarons, cakes, and other sumptuous creations. With owner and head baker Maarten Steenman practically a local baking legend at this point, there’s good reason this French-style patisserie is Read more...
    Main Photo by Village Creamery & Sweet Shop
  • 10. Lulu Cake Boutique

    If you haven't seen Lulu's show-stopping wedding and birthday cakes, prepare to be wowed. The treats are like works of art and are almost too pretty to eat. Don't let the beauty stop you from digging fork into cake, however. With flavors like organic carrot cake, dulce de leche, and strawberry cheesecake, these desserts are too tempting to pass Read more...

    11. Bluebird Homemade Ice Cream

    Best of Westchester 2018 - Best Coffee Ice Cream Where You Should Be Eating Ice Cream in Westchester Right Now Main photo by Amy R. Partridge
    Spawned by the son of New York City cookie icon William Greenberg Jr., this bakery offers plenty of mouth-watering baked goods, like sticky buns, rich chocolate brownies and a delectable coffee cake. Best of Westchester 20202 - Best Coffee Cake

    15. The Kneaded Bread

    Opened in 1998, this old-school Port Chester bakery has been cooking up local favorites for decades, from Irish soda bread at St. Pat's to challah for the high holy days, and every tasty confection in between.   Best of Westchester 2021 - Best Bakery (Bread) Best of Westchester 2020 - Best Bakery (Bread) Best of Read more...

    16. Bona Bona

    Flavors like Holy Cannoli, Rainbow Cookie, and Backyard Mint Chip, served in cones topped with torched Italian meringue, are reason enough to go, but what owner Nick Di Bona has created is a Willy Wonka-esque wonderland with a liquor-licensed milkshake bar, chocolate fountain, and party room that rains sprinkles from the ceiling.   Best of Read more...
  • 18. King Kone